Identification of Human Trafficking Victims in Health Care Settings

This is a long article that looked for patterns to better identify victims of child trafficking, when they receive medical care.

by Susie B. Baldwin, David P. Eisenman, Jennifer N. Sayles, Gery Ryan, Kenneth S. Chuang

Health & Human Rights Journal Vol 13, No 1 (2011)

Background

An estimated 18,000 individuals are trafficked into the United States each year from all over the world, and are forced into hard labor or commercial sex work. Despite their invisibility, some victims are known to have received medical care while under traffickers’ control. Our project aimed to characterize trafficking victims’ encounters in US health care settings.

Methods

The study consisted of semi-structured interviews with six Key Informants who work closely with trafficking victims (Phase I) and 12 female trafficking survivors (Phase II). All survivors were recruited through the Coalition to Abolish Slavery and Trafficking, an NGO in Los Angeles, and all were trafficked into Los Angeles. Interviews were conducted in English and six other languages, with the assistance of professional interpreters. Using a framework analysis approach that focused on victims’ encounters in health care settings, we assessed interview transcript content and coded for themes. We used an exploratory pile-sorting technique to aggregate similar ideas and identify overarching domains.

Results

The survivors came from 10 countries. Eight had experienced domestic servitude, three had survived sex trafficking, and one had experienced both. Half the survivors reported that they had visited a physician while in their traffickers’ control, and another worked in a health care facility. All Key Informants described other victims who had received medical care. For domestic servants, medical visits were triggered by injury and respiratory or systemic illness, while sex trafficking victims were seen by health professionals for sexually transmitted infections and abortion. Trafficking victims were prevented from disclosing their status to health care providers by fear, shame, language barriers, and limited interaction with medical personnel, among other obstacles.

Discussion

This exploration of survivors’ experiences in health care settings supports anecdotal reports that US health care providers may unwittingly encounter human trafficking victims. Increasing awareness of human trafficking, and modifying practice to facilitate disclosure, could improve victim identification.

Introduction

Human trafficking is modern-day slavery, a global industry of exploitation that generates billions of dollars in international profits each year.1 The United Nations defines human trafficking as “the recruitment, transportation, transfer, harbouring or receipt of persons, by means of the threat or use of force or other forms of coercion, of abduction, of fraud, of deception, of the abuse of power or of a position of vulnerability or of the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve the consent of a person having control over another person, for the purpose of exploitation.”2 In the US, the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (TVPA) of 2000 and subsequent TVPA reauthorizations codify human trafficking as a federal crime, create protections for victims, and strengthen the ability of the government to combat human trafficking internationally.

Though it is difficult to collect concrete data regarding the extent of human trafficking, the US is known to be a major trafficking destination.3 The State Department estimates that 18,000 women, men, and children are trafficked into the US each year from dozens of countries.4 Many victims arrive in the US through three main trafficking hubs: Los Angeles, New York City, and Miami, but as of 2004, forced labor victims had been identified in at least 90 US cities in 31 states.5, 6 In addition, thousands of US citizens, mostly women and children, are trafficked within US borders, primarily for sexual exploitation.

Once in the US, trafficked victims are absorbed into underground, unregulated sectors of the economy, where wage, health, and safety law violations routinely occur.5 In addition, thousands of US citizens, mostly women and children, are trafficked within US borders, primarily for sexual exploitation. Often, trafficking victims work as enslaved domestic servants or as forced laborers in the restaurant, agricultural, or manufacturing sectors. Trafficking victims are also coerced into prostitution, pornography, and other sectors of the commercial sex industry. Regardless of the form of their exploitation, people who are trafficked suffer intense abuse that often results in physical and mental illness.7

Encounters in the health care setting may offer opportunities for identification of trafficking victims. Based on a sample of 21 victims from San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Atlanta, The Family Violence Prevention Fund reported in 2005 that 28% received medical care while in their trafficker’s control.8 The US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), the federal agency responsible for assisting trafficking victims, supports the notion that health care providers can facilitate the identification and rescue of trafficking victims. In 2004, HHS initiated a campaign to increase awareness of human trafficking among professionals, including health care workers, who may unknowingly interact with trafficking victims in their daily work.9 According to subsequent HHS reporting based on information from law enforcement and service providers, health and dental clinic workers and emergency room personnel have served as sources of victim referrals.10

Despite such reports, few empirical data exist regarding trafficking victims’ interactions within US health care settings, and key questions require further examination. Are there certain settings, patient presentations and behaviors, or perpetrator characteristics that together may help identify a patient as a victim of human trafficking? What barriers prevent health care professionals from identifying trafficking victims? To better understand trafficking victims’ use of health services, this qualitative study explores and characterizes encounters in health care settings, as reported by trafficking survivors living in Los Angeles.

(Read the rest of the article and resources cited at the attached link)

http://www.hhrjournal.org/index.php/hhr/article/view/409/636

Posted in In the News | Leave a comment

Project Exodus Defends Victim

Two months ago Project Exodus was approached by a mother in duress. Her daughter, a victim of human trafficking, had been arrested for a crime that she was forced to commit by her pimp and abuser. Though the mother initially contacted us with the simple hope of attaining some advice, after hearing her situation we decided to support her.

In a big move for our organization, we decided to pay for a lawyer to represent the victim in criminal court. We felt that God had put this mother and victim in our path and that we were being called to give aid to them. Our hope by giving the victim a lawyer was to be able to defend her and prove that she was in fact a victim of a crime and not a criminal.

Though Project Exodus completely believes the innocence of the victim, proving that innocence is much more difficult in a court of law. What further makes the case difficult is the relative rarity of human trafficking cases that go in front of a court. Using human trafficking as a defense is difficult if the court is not familiar at all with human trafficking and its dynamics. For security reasons we cannot go into the details of the case but what we can say is that from the start we were facing an extreme uphill battle. God has been with us this entire time and true miracles have been happening but we still need help.

On Wednesday, 7/27/11, the court will make the final decision in regards to the future of the victim. If our defense holds, she will be put on probation. If it fails, she faces up to 20 years in prison. Our defense has been made, our letters have been read, and now we wait.

While we cannot be sure of the outcome of the trail, what we can be sure of is that we worship a God of justice who loves victims in a way we cannot even imagine. We also know that whatever we ask for in prayer, God will answer. Our God is a God who fights for justice on behalf of the oppressed. He is our sanctuary in times of need. He is our light in darkness. He is our hope when there is no hope to be found. In this time of need, we turn to God and ask him to hear our prayers.

We are asking that everyone please join us in a time of prayer for this victim of human trafficking. We ask that you please pray for God to move in the heart of the judge and let the judge understand the situation of our victim. We ask that you pray for the victim and her mother, that God gives them comfort in this time of trial. We ask that you pray for the trafficker of our victim, that he may realize the error of his ways and repent. We pray for justice. We pray for hope. We pray for freedom.

In addition to prayer, if you are willing and looking for further ways to become involved, we are asking for further support. In order to hire the lawyer, Project Exodus had to pay $2000. While this is an amazing deal for a laywer, the amount represents a considerable amount of money for our organization. If you feel led, we are asking you to consider supporting the trial by donating to Project Exodus. While we have already paid the money, the money donated will help regain our financial standing and allow us to invest in much needed surveillance equipment for our operation teams.

www.Project-Exodus.org

 

Posted in Organizations | Leave a comment

Forever Found’s 1st Annual Benefit Dinner & Silent Auction

Forever Found’s 1st Annual Benefit Dinner & Silent Auction. This event will raise continued support for children victimized by sexual slavery.

Key Speakers: Francis Chan & Phil Ludwig

Musical Performance by: Shannon Sergey, Forever Found President

Come prepared to bid on irresistible auction items!

WHEN: Thursday, September 22, 2011

6PM - Registration & Cocktail Hour

6PM – Silent Auction Open

7PM – Dinner & Program

Where:   Wood Ranch Golf Club   301 Wood Ranch Parkway    Simi Valley, CA 93065

Complimentary Valet Parking, Business or Cocktail Attire

www.foreverfound.org/

Posted in Events, Organizations | Leave a comment

State PTA Convention in Long Beach Raises Awareness

The annual California State Parent Teacher Association Convention hosted a workshop to raise awareness.  Volunteers from schools all over California learned about how child trafficking is a growing crime and how pimps lure junior high girls into prostitution.
A San Diego Detective shared that 80% of the young girls pimped on the streets in San Diego were obtained from California schools.  This was surprising, because many people assumed they were imported from Mexico.

He also shared that a girl may need to be rescued several times, because the pimps are extremely controlling and effective in re-acquiring the girls from state agencies.

The Detective helped workshop attendees understand that the girls are victims of manipulation and that the pimps are the real criminals.  Twelve year old girls don’t naturally decide to start a career as a prostitute.

Posted in Events, Organizations | Leave a comment